I just read yet another commentator who has taken the position that (as a teacher) they saw no problem with mandatory posting of the Ten Commandments in schools because the laws don't refer to any specific religion. That is utter nonsense and particularly disturbing if they are truly a teacher. You can't have read the Decalogue and make that statement. Alternatively, they are intentionally blowing smoke knowing that people are too lazy to find their Bible. As a committed agnostic, mine is always on my nightstand.
The first four commandments (depending on the scriptural flavor you choose) are either specifically about the ancient Hebrew battle god YHWH, or have nothing to do with ethical or moral behavior.
1. The first commandment specifically instructs us to love YWHW and no other gods.
“I am the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. Thou shall have no other gods before me.”
That sentence pertains only to YHWH, not to the rebranded Christian god (God), not to Allah, especially not to elephant headed, multi-armed polytheistic pantheons as define Hinduism, not to practitioners of indigenous spirituality, not to Buddhists not to Taoists. Do the Muslim students in class identify with slaughtering Egyptian children in the night?
It certainly has no positive meaning for the 28% of Americans who identify as “no religion.”
2. Prohibition on “graven images.” So is this going to be a big problem in Catholic Schools in Louisiana or are they exempt? There is no graven image law in the Catholic Bible. If the Louisiana government chooses the Protestant version of the 10C for schools, the second commandment will be targeted to Catholic statuary and even crucifix jewelry. The graven image thing is very tricky, but however you interpret it, it has nothing to do with any ethical or moral behavior. Two down.
3: Taking the Lord’s name in vain. A lot of people think this applies to general swearing (H-E- double-hockey-sticks is a good hack that always fools the Lord) but that’s not the case. The original context was that the sacred name of YHWH could not be used in magic spells. In other words, it was a prohibition against competing priests/shamans usurping Levite power. It wasn’t about the F word or the S word. It was about magical competition, like stealing a spell at Hogwarts.
4: Keeping one or other of the Sabbaths: Which Sabbath shall we celebrate, Saturday or Sunday? And this is important for you sinners out there who sneak out to work on the Sabbath, because YWHW proclaimed the death penalty for those who work on the Lord’s day.
“Six days work shall be done, but on the seventh day you shall have a Sabbath of solemn rest, holy to the LORD. Whoever does any work on it shall be put to death.” – Ex. 35:2.
Clear enough?
Shut down that lawn mower and get inside before He notices.